[ 362 ]

Jan. 1st, 2023 09:44 pm
katara: (Phoenix .:. 14)
[personal profile] katara



Title: Persephone

Series: Into Shadow

Author: Lev Grossman

Genre: Short Stories, Fantasy, Science Fiction, Dystopia

Date Started: January 1st, 2023

Date Finished: January 1st, 2023

Status: Finished

Rating: 1/5

Sypnosis: A teenage nobody crosses a line that will change her life forever in this short coming-of-age story by number one New York Times bestselling author Lev Grossman.

Ever since her dad disappeared five years ago, Persephone has quietly walled off the feelings she’d rather not feel. There’s no room for pain or anger when you’re just trying to get through the hell that is high school. But one day, the crush of taunts and disappointments is finally too much—and a power breaks loose inside her that she never knew was there.

Review: Ugh!

A wannabe X-Men. Call in Professor Xavier!

But it had a ton of potential to be something much more interesting. Unfortunately, the author decided to make this one a simple short story.

Don't get me wrong; short stories are great if they have the ability to wrap up something nice and sweet. These don't do it. They leave more questions than answers, which is a real pity. I could have enjoyed this book immensely if it had been a bit longer and the world-building had been fleshed out more. Even the characters seemed to be one-dimensional.

I don't think I will try any of the other short stories.

[ 361 ]

Jan. 1st, 2023 08:23 pm
katara: (Phoenix .:. 3)
[personal profile] katara



Title: The Garden

Series: Into Shadow

Author: Tomi Adeyemi

Genre: Fantasy, Short Stories, Magical Realism

Date Started: January 1st, 2023

Date Finished: January 1st, 2023

Status: Finished

Rating: .5/5

Sypnosis: In this dreamlike short story told in alternating prose and verse, number one New York Times bestselling author Tomi Champion-Adeyemi weaves a tale of a young woman’s journey to find her mother and uncover her secrets.

Fifteen years ago, Lęina’s mother, Yuliana, went searching for a mythical place called the Garden and never returned. Determined to learn the truth about what happened, Lęina travels to Brazil to search for the hidden realm, with Yuliana’s journal and a local tour guide leading the way. But Lęina soon begins to wonder if she’s looking for answers—or if what she truly wants to find is herself.

Review: ....what did I just read?

This story was so short that it had no substance to maintain it. There was nothing to make this story interesting except all the plotholes left throughout it. So many questions.

How did she get her mother's journal? How did she know the path? What is the story behind the whole thing?

I can understand a nice, short story for the audience but don't do something like this and leave out so much that people don't understand or confuse the hell out of them.

This story was a complete miss for me.

Profile

ebookreview: (Default)
A Reader's Guide to Books and Reviews

April 2025

S M T W T F S
   1 2345
6789 101112
1314 1516 171819
20212223242526
27282930   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Apr. 23rd, 2025 07:51 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios